diff --git a/utility/remove_inactive_users.py b/utility/remove_inactive_users.py
index 53c370b..b047773 100644
--- a/utility/remove_inactive_users.py
+++ b/utility/remove_inactive_users.py
@@ -122,6 +122,7 @@ def main():
             except KeyError:
                 print('User: {} has records in Tautulli but does not exist in Plex.'.format(username))
                 last_entry(last_seen, username)
+                continue
         else:
             # Only users that still exist in Plex will continue
             if username not in USER_IGNORE: